Choosing the right hardwood floor isn’t easy. There are so many options out there, and they all seem to look good. But not every wood suits every home. That’s why Flooring Surgeons is here to help. We’ve narrowed it down to the two most popular choices: oak and maple. Be with us to know which option is the best for you.
When it comes to maple vs. oak, both are excellent flooring options, but each has its own unique characteristics. If you’re comparing maple flooring vs. oak, you may find that each wood offers different benefits depending on your home’s style and needs. Maple vs. oak flooring: a tricky choice made simple – in this blog post, we will break down the key differences to help you make an informed decision on the best option for your space.
Table of contents
What is the Difference Between Maple and Oak Flooring?
Both Maple and Oak are hardwood flooring options, but they differ in appearance, durability, maintenance, and cost.
Oak flooring is strong and reliable. It has a natural, varied grain pattern that hides wear well. It’s also much more moisture-resistant, making it a good choice for high-traffic or humid areas like hallways and kitchens.
Maple flooring has a smooth, clean look that fits modern interiors. It’s also very durable, but it can be harder to stain evenly. Maple needs more careful maintenance to avoid scratches and discolouration over time.
When considering oak vs maple flooring, it’s essential to think about your specific needs—whether it’s the robust durability of oak or the sleek, modern aesthetic of maple.
A common question that arises when deciding between the two is, Is maple flooring harder than oak? While both are durable hardwoods, oak tends to be slightly harder than maple, which makes it a better choice for areas with heavy foot traffic or where long-term resilience is crucial.
Appearance: Maple vs. Oak Flooring Colours and Grain
Oak flooring is known for its warm colour and strong grain. It comes in red and white varieties, with shades that range from light to medium brown. The grain gives the floor a natural look and helps hide small scratches or dents. Because of this, oak works well in both traditional and modern homes. It is both good-looking and durable, which makes it a popular choice.
If you’re considering an alternative that combines the beauty of oak with affordability, check out Oak Laminate Flooring for a practical option that offers similar aesthetics at a lower cost.
Durability: Is Maple or Oak Flooring Stronger?
When it comes to durability, both maple and oak are strong hardwoods, but there are some differences. Based on the Janka hardness scale, maple is slightly harder than oak. This means it resists dents and wear a bit better. That’s why it is often used in sports courts and high-traffic areas. However, oak is still very durable and has the advantage of hiding scratches better, thanks to its grain pattern.
In conclusion, if you are choosing maple flooring for a high-traffic area that is prone to scratches, you are making the right decision. Keep this in mind:
- Maple flooring is more resistant to scratches,
- Oak flooring hides the scratches better.
One of the first questions to ask when weighing the options for oak vs. maple flooring is how each will hold up in your home. If you are looking for a wood that will resist scratches and general wear and tear, a comparison of red oak vs. maple might be useful to explore, as red oak comes with its own special strengths for durability.
Hardness and Scratch Resistance: Is Maple Stronger Than Oak?
Maple is harder than oak according to the Janka hardness scale, which means it is more resistant to dents and scratches. Maple vs. oak flooring is a common choice for people looking for a hardwood floor that can stand up to a lot of foot traffic or heavy use. Even though maple is harder, oak vs. maple hardwood flooring is still a popular choice for many homeowners because it can better conceal scratches than other woods, thanks to its grain pattern.
When considering maple vs oak flooring cost, maple may be slightly more expensive than oak because it is harder and less readily available, but it may be a good investment if you are concerned about scratches and durability.
Maintenance: How Easy Is It to Care for Maple and Oak Floors?
To make your decision confidently, you need to know how easy it is to clean oak and maple flooring. As mentioned previously, oak flooring hides everything better than maple flooring. On the other hand, maple flooring is very smooth and even, so stains, dust, and dirt are more noticeable. Plus, maple is more sensitive to humidity, so you need to keep indoor conditions stable. If you don’t mind cleaning your hardwood flooring more often, maple can be a great option. And if you’re not a fan of daily cleaning, oak is the better choice.
Are you looking for the best solid wood flooring options available in the UK? Flooring Surgeons is here for you.
Cost Comparison: How Much Do Maple and Oak Flooring Cost in the UK?
Oak flooring offers a wide price range starting from just £22.99 per m2, making it accessible for various budgets. Maple flooring, while not currently available at Flooring Surgeons, generally comes at a higher price point.
When choosing between maple and oak flooring, consider both the material and installation costs to align with your budget and design preferences. If you need further details or assistance in making your choice, feel free to contact Flooring Surgeons for expert guidance.
Maple vs. Oak Flooring: Installation Tips for British Homes
Before installing oak or maple flooring in British homes, it’s important to let the boards adjust to room conditions. For solid wood, it can take about seven days, while engineered wood can take around three days. The subfloor must be clean, dry, and flat. Maple is smooth and shows flaws more easily, so it requires a very level surface. Maple flooring vs oak requires more accurate fitting, as maple tends to be less forgiving when it comes to minor imperfections.
Oak has a stronger grain, which hides small gaps or uneven spots better. That makes oak vs maple hardwood flooring easier to work with, especially in older houses. After installation, keep the room temperature and humidity steady to prevent damage.
When considering maple vs oak flooring cost, maple may be slightly more expensive, but it offers a smooth, modern look and greater scratch resistance. Oak, on the other hand, is more widely available and generally more affordable.
Best Rooms for Maple and Oak Flooring in UK Houses
Oak flooring is a better option for high-traffic areas and rooms. These include hallways, kitchens, entryways, and living rooms. Oak hides scratches and dirt well, so it’s great for busy areas. It’s also a good choice for houses that are rather old, where the subfloor may not be perfect.
Maple flooring works better in bedrooms, home offices, and dining rooms. It has a clean, modern look and fits quiet spaces where there’s less foot traffic. Because it can show scratches more easily, it’s best in areas with light use.
Environmental Impact: Choosing Sustainable Maple or Oak Flooring
Both maple and white oak can be smart choices for the environment, as long as they’re sourced the right way. White oak grows fast and is considered a renewable wood. Many suppliers use sustainable methods to reduce harm to nature. Maple is also widely available and is harvested in a way that keeps forests healthy.
To make sure your flooring is eco-friendly, look for FSC or PEFC certification. These labels show the wood comes from responsibly managed forests. With the right supplier, both maple and oak flooring can be sustainable and long-lasting options for your home.
If you’re interested in a more eco-conscious choice, explore our Oak Engineered Flooring for a sustainable and durable flooring solution.
Maple Flooring Pros and Cons (UK Guide)
Maple flooring is a popular choice for modern homes. Here are some pros and cons to help you decide if it’s right for you:
| Maple Flooring Pros | Maple Flooring Cons |
| Clean, light, modern look | Shows scratches and dirt easily |
| Very durable and hard | Harder to stain evenly |
| Works well in low-traffic areas | Less forgiving on uneven subfloors |
| Great for bedrooms and offices | Can react to changes in humidity |
| Smooth surface feels polished | Usually imported, so higher carbon footprint |
| Often used in minimalist designs | Needs more careful maintenance |
Oak Flooring Pros and Cons (UK Guide)
Oak flooring is known for its classic look and strong performance. Let’s take a quick look at its advantages and drawbacks:
| Oak Flooring Pros | Oak Flooring Cons |
| Warm, natural tones | Needs regular care to stay in top shape |
| Strong grain hides marks well | Harder to stain evenly |
| Good for high-traffic areas | Grain pattern may not suit all styles |
| More forgiving during installation | Colour can darken with age |
| Easier to refinish and stain | Can be pricier depending on the type |
| Often used in minimalist designs |
Which Is Better for High-Traffic Areas: Maple or Oak Floors?
Oak is definitely a better option for high-traffic areas like hallways, kitchens, and living rooms because:
- It has a strong, visible grain that hides scratches and dirt
- It’s more forgiving on uneven subfloors
- It handles daily wear better without showing damage
- It needs less frequent cleaning to stay looking good
Which Wood Performs Better in Humid Areas: Maple or Oak?
If you are considering the maple vs. oak flooring cost, then you have to factor in which one works best in your environment. Maple and oak both work well, but oak wins out in humid environments because it has natural moisture resistance.
Does maple flooring have a harder wear surface than oak? Yes, maple is usually harder but not as stable in humid areas as oak.
If you have been debating the decision between maple vs. oak flooring, we have made the choice easy by giving you the strengths and weaknesses of each type of flooring in different environments, so you can make the right decision for your home.
How to Choose Between Maple and Oak Flooring for Your Home?
Choosing between maple and oak depends on your home, your needs, and your style. Here’s what to think about before you decide between flooring options:
- The room use
- The look you want
- The lighting
- Your lifestyle
- Your budget
- Sustainability
By carefully considering these factors, you can make a well-informed decision. If you’re still unsure, feel free to reach out to Flooring Surgeons for expert advice tailored to your specific needs.
Maple vs. Oak: Which Wood Flooring Adds More Value to Your UK Home?
Both maple and oak can add value to your home, but oak is usually the better choice in the UK. Oak is more common and matches well with furniture and different home styles. Maple can add value too, especially in modern houses. But it’s less familiar to UK buyers and may not fit every taste. If you want a safer option with better resale value, oak is the best pick.
Before you make your decision, we recommend you seek professional help from experts at Flooring Surgeons.
Conclusion: Should You Buy Maple or Oak Flooring in the UK?
Both maple and oak are excellent choices for hardwood flooring, each bringing unique characteristics to a space. Your selection should align with your aesthetic preferences, budget, and the specific demands of your living environment.
When comparing maple flooring vs oak flooring, it’s important to consider factors such as durability, appearance, and cost. On the other hand, maple vs oak wood flooring comes down to the desired look and feel for your space, whether you prefer the modern smoothness of maple or the timeless grain of oak.
If you need further assistance in choosing the right flooring for your home, feel free to reach out or visit our showrooms for personalised guidance. Our experts at Flooring Surgeons are here to help you make the best decision, whether you’re leaning toward the timeless elegance of oak or the sleek modernity of maple. Let us help you find the perfect fit for your home! Still unsure about your flooring choice? Discover how engineered wood compares to laminate and whether it could be the perfect fit for your home in our detailed article here: Is Engineered Wood Better than Laminate?.
fatemexrm
fatemexrm is a contributor at Flooring Surgeons, sharing insights and expertise through published articles.
